When looking at extensions in the Vanilla add-on area and I see a 3 star or 4 star rank I wonder why it's not 5 stars. Just a request to let people comment on their rank, maybe they encountered some problems we need to know about. This always helps me on sites like Version Tracker so I can see what the good and bad parts of programs are. Any possiblity on this?
Personally: I reserve 5 stars for something that I find invaluable, really outstanding. If I give a 3 or 4, then it works great and I like it, but I could technically live without it. :)
this is something that Mark has had on the back burner for a while. i know because i was the first one to request it when the addons site was new and he told me he had already been thinking about it :)
hopefully he'll have time to get to it soon - i agree that this would be helpful for add-on developers as well as users.