I'm not a fan of the header image but the general look is quite nice. I like the grey stripe running along underneath the tabs. That's really nicely done :)
I thing its alright. The black lines could do with being a dark grey, they wont be so harsh that way, also the border around the quickjump looks a bit strange.
Not a bad start, It still looks fairly plain however and could use some more edges to help break up discussions and topics up from one another. But not bad, I like.
For me, the actual text of a comment is offset to the right. That could do with changing. Oh and I don't like those giant comment boxes for such a little comment.
I like it. I think its probably the most 'different' style i've seen so far for vanilla.
Things I like: - the header looks cool - infact i like the entire 'top part' of the site
Things i don't like: - the black borders are a bit harsh as said previously - not kean on the redy/pink colour used for unread comments - although the avatar is a good idea, doesnt work for me
generally a cool looking theme though... could look very nice if polished up a little more and some slight recolouring.
Hmm, i dont mind it. Not my favourite. Again its different which is nice to see. I think the avatars down the side might help win over a couple of the phpBB/etc lovers slightly more which could be a plus.